The Isle of Man’s gas supply network is to be regulated for the first time

Bills should be lower, says OFT

Bills should be lower, says OFT

  • OFT announces deal

  • Gas prices rose last year because of mild winter

  • Deal is voluntary, not compulsory

Have your say

The island’s gas supply network is to be regulated for the first time.

The Office of Fair Trading, the Treasury and the Department of Economic Development today announced a historic voluntary agreement with Manx Gas.

Tony Nicholls of Manx Gas

Tony Nicholls of Manx Gas

OFT chairman David Quirk MHK said: ‘For many years there has been concern from consumers about gas prices and the OFT has been carefully monitoring the market for over a decade.

‘In 2008, the Council of Ministers published an OFT report under the Fair Trading Act 1996 into gas prices.

‘Based on specialist economic advice, the report defined an acceptable range of profitability and concluded that the profits of Manx Gas were not excessive.

‘Since then, Manx Gas has adopted the mid-point of that acceptable range and has been providing the OFT with confidential data, which has confirmed that the company has been complying with its voluntary policy.

This is a voluntary system of regulation which contractually commits Manx Gas to a level of profitability which is below their previous target

David Quirk MHK

‘What we are announcing today is a formal voluntary system of regulation which contractually commits Manx Gas to a level of profitability which is below their previous target; and ultimately that means a better deal for consumers.’

The 2008 report concluded that the most appropriate way of measuring profitability in an industry requiring a high level of capital investment, such as gas supply, was the relationship between profits and the capital cost of the assets used to produce those profits.

This concept (which is referred to by accountants and economists as Return on Capital Employed or ROCE) is widely used by utilities regulators, the OFT says.

The OFT said that ROCE was a measure of profitability; it was not the profit margin. The business would set its prices and margins to achieve the level of profitability.

David Quirk MHK

David Quirk MHK

Many consumers were horrified last year when Manx Gas put up prices because the weather had turned mild and profits were therefore hit.

Click here to be reminded of that story.

At the time, the OFT justified the situation by saying that the figures were a part of the agreement with the government.

But even the Chief Minsiter thought that the situation was ’a bit off’.

Today Mr Quirk said: ‘Up to now, Manx Gas has been targeting a rolling average ROCE of 10.6 per cent.

‘The new voluntary agreement, which came into effect on January 1, will result in a ROCE of 9.99 per cent.

‘The agreement runs for a minimum of four years and we estimate that it will give a saving to the island’s consumers of over £2m over that period, compared to the previous system.

‘Company accounts information and other data will be supplied to the OFT and with assistance from Treasury accountants, we will be able to rigorously monitor compliance with the agreement.

‘Manx Gas will still set its tariffs and prices as it has always done, but under the agreement those will have to achieve the agreed ROCE of 9.99 per cent.’

Tony Nicholls, managing director of Manx Gas said: ‘We are pleased that a formal voluntary regulatory agreement is now in place.

‘For the first time, stakeholders will have a clear framework within which performance will be measured.

‘The terms of the agreement are challenging but fair and will enable us to plan for future investment in the network.

‘We look forward to working with the OFT and Treasury to ensure the new regulatory environment delivers benefits to all stakeholders.’

So why is this a voluntary agreement rather than one that could be enforced in law?

Mr Quirk said: ‘We could have looked to introduce statutory regulation but it would have been costly, probably confrontational and would, at the end of the day, have most likely only produced a similar result – any savings achieved for customers would be offset by the cost to tax payers of fully regulating the market.

‘Ultimately, however, prices are always going to be driven by the forward purchase cost of gas on the futures market.’

The OFT will publish the agreement on its website at this site tomorrow

Related story:

The government bankrolls Manx Gas’s pipeline.

Back to the top of the page