There’s a credible case to hold another Big Manx Feast festival, the government agency that organised it says - despite the inaugural event making a loss of over £85,000.

The Big Manx Feast was set up following widespread criticism over the cancellation of the popular Isle of Man Food and Drink Festival in 2024.

Held in Noble’s Park over two days in September, it attracted over 6,000 visitors - but this was well below the original target of 10,000 to 12,000.

It cost £170,839 to stage but total income was just £85,795 including £36,660 in ticket sales, £31,500 in sponsorship, £12,185 in vendor pitch fees.

This left a net cost of £85,045.

Of the 26 confirmed producer and artisan businesses, seven withdrew, leaving just 19 participants, reducing the range of local produce that was on offer.

In a post-event report, Business Isle of Man says it ‘considers there to be a credible case to hold another Big Manx Feast event’.

However, it warns, the event is unlikely to break even and remains exposed to the risk of poor ticket sales, adverse weather, cancellation, inflation and unforeseen costs.

It says holding a very similar event, on similar dates and in the same location, may not maximise return on investment and may expose the department to health and safety related risks, or an excessively high risk of cancellation.

The event generated a minimum £125,000 in income for participating vendors and is estimated to have stimulated over £454,000 in direct and indirect revenue for local businesses.

Feedback from visitors was overwhelmingly positive and most of the producer and artisan stall holders who did attend said they would probably return.

But Business Isle of Man had not anticipated, given the event’s perceived position as a flagship opportunity for local producers, that so many participants would withdraw.

Reasons cited included insufficient stock, staffing shortages, event timing, reluctance to commit to a new festival, pitch fees and wider business constraints.

Feedback from prospective vendors was that pitch fees were too high.

Poor weather on the Friday resulted in extra costs for more matting and woodchip, impacted attractions, caused significant health and safety risks, and delayed plans resulting in long working hours and work being undertaken in the dark.

Several costs were high than expected including those for marquees, electricity and marketing.

The report says the suitability of Noble’s Park should be reassessed in terms of cost, capacity, accessibility, traffic management, health and safety and resilience to adverse weather.

It says future plans should include more covered seating and a review of ticket prices.

Business Isle of Man took over the responsibility for the rebranded event from DEFA following the cancellation of the 2024 Food and Drink Festival.

Sponsored by Isle of Man Creamery, the Big Manx Feast’s programme included chef demonstrations across the Cookery Theatre and Manx Meat Shack outdoor cooking zone, featuring more than Manx producers, local chefs and five guest chefs from the UK.