The deputy returning officer for Onchan says he takes full responsibility for errors made on the night of the constituency’s election count.
In a report to Deemster Andrew Corlett, Jeremy Callin says it is clear that two sets of ballots were not correctly accounted for.
This resulted in 100 votes for candidates Peter Karran and Mr Callister not being counted at all and 25 plump votes for candidate Rachel Glover being counted for Gabriella Corkish instead.
Mr Callin notes: ‘This was clearly a very serious administrative error which was compounded by an insufficient cross-check of the tabulated votes to the total ballot papers issued and a failure to recognise the importance of any discrepancy between the two.
‘These were errors that were made on the night of the Onchan constituency count and for which I, and I alone, accept complete responsibility.’
He adds: ‘I apologise unreservedly to the Honourable Court and the candidates for these errors.’
But Mr Callin says the error did not in any way change the outcome of the election which saw Dr Rachel Glover and Rob Callister returned as MHKs for Onchan.
Defeated candidate Julie Edge lodged a high court petition called for the election result to be declared void, alleging the constituency's vote count did not comply with election law.
Ms Edge said that 79 ballot papers were unaccounted for, and claimed candidates had insufficient opportunity to request a recount and postal votes were opened without notice.
Her petition resulted in a supervised recount being held this month in a courtroom at the Courts of Justice.
The results following the recount were Rachel Glover 1,252, up from 1,245; Rob Callister 1,184, up from 1,103; Julie Edge 858, down from 866; Peter Karran 838, up from 738; Gabriella Corkish 703, down from 725; and Oliver Lockwood 50, no change from previously.
Mr Callin concludes in his report: ‘It is equally clear that Ms Edge lost the election.’
The deputy returning officer says there were further minor discrepancies that resulted in no net change which he says were examples of human error and ‘in reality likely to be inevitable’.
‘These discrepancies clearly should not have happened but they did occur and I think they would probably occur in any forensic recount of a vote,’ he says.
Mr Callin concludes, however, that the election process worked correctly and the election was conducted in full compliance with the law and that ‘no act or omission affected the result’.
He says it is quite clear from the examination of unused ballot papers and the counterfoils of used ballot papers that the number of ballot papers issued tallied with the number counted, taking into account rejected papers.
‘There was therefore no failing in the system or the process,’ he says.


-(3).jpeg?width=209&height=140&crop=209:145,smart&quality=75)
-and-James-Hampton-(candidate-in-Glenfaba-and.jpeg?width=209&height=140&crop=209:145,smart&quality=75)
