External validation inspectors have published a glowing report into Rushen Primary School.

But the report on their first inspection of the school two years ago has still not been released.

Isle of Man Today has made a number of requests to the Department of Education, Sport and Culture for a copy of the 2024 investigation report by Etio, formerly Tribal Education Services.

Our initial Freedom of Information request was refused on the grounds that the report would be released at a later date, when the external validation process was complete.

But two years on, the department has refused our second FoI, saying publication of the report would ‘prejudice the effective conduct of public business’.

It pointed out there has since been a change in school leadership and there was a high probability that the information could be ‘taken out of context or mis-interpreted’ and would not reflect the school’s current position, priorities or direction.

Media IoM has requested a review of that decision, arguing that this is not a valid ground for an exemption - and pointing out that the changes made at the school since 2024 could be dealt with by way of a commentary attached to the FoI response.

An external school inspection process should be transparent, we point out, and all reports - whatever their contents - should be published.

Etio inspectors visited Rushen Primary School again on October 19 and 20 this year.

They hailed its inclusive culture and caring and welcoming environment ‘where learners, staff and families feel valued and part of the school community’.

It says staff feel trusted, valued and supported by leaders and their colleagues and positive relationships between staff and learners help create a calm school.

Rushen Primary took part in the pilot for the new school validation quality assurance process in June 2024.

Days later, the then head and deputy head were seconded to other duties with immediate effect.