Should police investigate complaints made against themselves?
That was the question put to Justice Minister Jane Poole-Wilson as she faced a grilling in Tynwald over the Isle of Man's police complaints system.
Mrs Poole-Wilson admitted there was scope to strengthen independent oversight but defended the current arrangements, saying it was appropriate for the Chief Constable to remain responsible for administering complaints.
She also revealed that proposed changes to the law are not expected to go out to public consultation until the second quarter of 2027.
The issue was raised by Douglas East MHK Joney Faragher, who asked when the government intended to establish a system in which all complaints against Isle of Man Constabulary officers were investigated independently from the outset.
It follows repeated calls for greater independence, with concerns about the current system dating back almost 20 years.
Under the existing arrangements, complaints are initially passed to the Constabulary's Professional Standards Department, which notifies the independent Police Complaints Commissioner.
The Commissioner can supervise investigations and must do so in certain serious cases, but responsibility for administering the complaints process remains with the Chief Constable.
Mrs Poole-Wilson said she intended to bring forward changes to modernise the framework, but explained that work initially expected to be completed through secondary legislation had revealed that amendments to the Police Act 1993 were also needed.
.jpeg?trim=312,1,2466,0&width=752&height=501&crop=752:501)
‘Simply not good enough’: Health Minister delivers damning verdict on Manx Care
‘One-man complaints department’: MHK questions powers of Isle of Man Housing Minister
Tynwald sitting back underway after person falls in public gallery
Excitement builds as Awards for Excellence prepares for landmark 20th anniversary
She said: ‘The present policy direction is to strengthen the commissioner's independent oversight, supervision, and review functions, and to provide a clearer route for suitably qualified external investigators where required.’
However, she would not commit to a date for introducing the legislation itself.
Ms Faragher pointed out that the Minister had also promised improvements to the complaints process in July 2025 and questioned why progress had been so slow.
She said calls for independence had been ‘decades in the making’ and asked whether it was appropriate for the Chief Constable to control the entire process, including deciding which complaints should be formally investigated.
Mrs Poole-Wilson defended the system by comparing it with arrangements in England and Wales, where most complaints are also handled by individual police forces.
She also pointed to Jersey, which has its own Professional Standards Department.
But Ms Faragher challenged that comparison, arguing the Isle of Man did not have the same wider accountability arrangements as England and Wales, including police and crime commissioners.
Pressed again on whether she believed it was appropriate for the Chief Constable to retain responsibility, Mrs Poole-Wilson replied: ‘So I do think that is an appropriate mechanism.’
.jpeg?trim=321,1,2457,0&width=752&height=501&crop=752:501)
She added, however, that independent oversight was vital and there was an opportunity to introduce a system that was ‘suitably independent, proportionate, and cost-effective’ and commanded public confidence.
The Minister also revealed that 31 formal complaints relating to police conduct had been recorded during the most recent reporting period.
Of the 15 complaints which had been investigated, concluded and included in the Police Complaints Commissioner's annual report laid before Tynwald in July, five were partially substantiated.
Mrs Poole-Wilson said those five involved only minor elements of complaints, such as isolated instances of inappropriate language. None was wholly substantiated, while the remaining 10 were wholly unsubstantiated.
She said she had asked the Chief Constable to improve the administration of the system and provide complainants with more timely updates. All investigations have also been required to be completed within three months.
The Minister said consultation on legislative changes was planned for April to June 2027, although she stopped short of promising when the legislation would be brought before Tynwald.
The issue is also being pursued by Arbory, Castletown and Malew MHK Kirrie Jenkins, who has tabled a written question asking what plans the department has to revise the police complaints investigation process.
Mrs Poole-Wilson has until November 25 to respond.



Comments
We've recently changed our login process. If you have an account for commenting, you will need to re-register on the login window.
This article has no comments yet. Be the first to leave a comment.