Tighter immigration rules could leave Isle of Man employers struggling to fill vacancies and threaten some existing businesses, the Enterprise Minister has warned.
Rushen MHK Mark Kemp asked a series of written Tynwald questions about government assessments of the Worker Migrant and Global Business Mobility immigration routes.
Mr Kemp's questions covered the potential consequences for businesses and public services, including schools, housing and transport.
The Worker Migrant route was introduced in April 2018, with significant changes made in June this year, including higher minimum salary thresholds and restrictions on bringing in dependants.
The amendments were intended to tackle abuses of the immigration system, including fraudulent applications, exploitation and people remaining on the island after their permission expires.
In his written response, Enterprise Minister Robert Cowell said the changes were expected to reduce overall worker numbers, with hospitality and tourist accommodation among the sectors most affected.
He said many employers would be unable to fill certain vacancies through the immigration system under the revised rules.
Mr Cowell warned: ‘This could limit business expansion and investment and, in some cases, affect the sustainability of existing operations on the island which could impact existing island workers.’
He said a comprehensive economic impact assessment and consultation before the changes were introduced could have undermined their effectiveness, given the risks they were intended to address.
The Global Business Mobility route was introduced at the beginning of November, replacing the Intra-Company Transfer element of the Worker Migrant route for new applicants.
It brings the island more closely into line with the UK's immigration arrangements but is temporary and offers no route to settlement.
Mr Cowell said it was designed to support specific business activities and access to specialist expertise, rather than provide a general means of filling vacancies in the local labour market.
Education Minister Sarah Maltby said her department did not hold figures identifying how many children joining island schools had recently arrived specifically because of migration.
She acknowledged that the Global Business Mobility route could bring workers with dependent children to the island, potentially increasing demand for school places.
However, she said this would not, in itself, create a significant capacity problem across the education system.
Home Affairs Minister Jane Poole-Wilson said £1.2m had been allocated to strengthen border and immigration controls.
Her department assessed that the recent immigration changes did not introduce additional risks.
Treasury Minister Michael Crowe said the newly created Border Division had commissioned Treasury's Economic Advisory to examine the fiscal implications of migration.
Its report found that working-age migrants were, on average, likely to contribute more in public revenue than they cost, while non-working dependants, particularly children and older relatives, were more likely to generate net fiscal costs over the medium term.
Infrastructure Minister Jason Moorhouse said his department had not carried out a specific assessment of extra demand for housing, transport and waste services resulting from the changes to immigration routes.

.png?trim=0,244,0,356&width=752&height=501&crop=752:501)



