Three Isle of Man immigration service decisions to refuse entry clearance or further leave to remain have been upheld after appeals were dismissed.

In one case, a British national living in Hong Kong was refused entry after he declared a conviction for indecent assault dating back to 1988.

Chun Kuen Sze maintained in his appeal that the offence was at the lowest level of severity and was dealt with by way of a fine of HKD 2,500.

He said the incident happened on a crowded rush hour train at Tsim Sha Tsui station, Hong Kong. The appellant told the immigration officer: ‘People pushing out of and into the carriage were not very courteous, and physical contact and bumping were common.

‘Suddenly, a woman behind me grabbed my hand and accused me of indecently assaulting her, claiming that I had touched her buttocks. I was completely shocked and didn't have time to react. She immediately pulled me off the train onto the platform, saying she was going to call the police.’

Rejecting his appeal, immigration adjudicator Christopher Arrowsmith said he did not accept that the level of the fine imposed necessarily demonstrated the absence of serious harm.

He pointed out: ‘This indecent assault occurred in a public place, to a female victim, using public transport.

‘On balance I conclude that an indecent assault would amount to causing serious harm in the known circumstances, limited as they are.’

In a second case, a child, now aged 16 and referred to as A, was refused entry clearance.

The child’s mother is a Philippine national who has been lawfully resident in the Isle of Man as a worker migrant since January 2025.

Their father resides in the Philippines as does the child, in the care of a maternal aunt.

Upholding the decision to refuse entry clearance, immigration adjudicator James Brooks noted the appellant had lived apart from the mother for at least seven years - and there was no serious and compelling family consideration not to refuse the application.

The third case involved a worker migrant who was refused leave to remain.

Louis Tlou was granted leave to remain in October 2022 with a visa linked to his employment with Auto Solutions. But in mid-2023 he took a new job, with RRG Group in Huddersfield.

But in December last year, his employment was terminated following a change in UK immigration rules which led to the visa salary' requirement being above that for the role he held.

Mr Tlou obtained an offer of employment back in the Isle of Man.

Rejecting his appeal against the decision to refuse him further leave to remain, immigration adjudicator Mr Brooks said the appellant had taken up employment with another employer in breach of his visa conditions.

He accepted that once it became apparent to Mr Tlou that there were issues with his immigration status in terms of his employment with the UK employer, he ceased that employment.

Mr Brooks said he understood that the appellant may view the immigration officer’s decision as disproportionate but said he must apply the rules as they are.