Tynwald members will have the chance next month to call for an independent system for investigating complaints against island police officers.
Douglas East MHK Joney Faragher has tabled a motion urging the Council of Ministers to bring forward legislation to establish a system in which complaints are investigated independently of the Isle of Man Constabulary from the outset.
Ms Faragher's motion, due to be considered in December, calls upon the Council of Ministers to bring forward, within six months, legislative proposals to establish a ‘genuinely independent system’ where all complaints are investigated at first instance by an independent body.
Under the current system, complaints are initially passed to the Constabulary's Professional Standards Department, which notifies the independent Police Complaints Commissioner. The Commissioner can supervise investigations, but responsibility for administering the process remains with the Chief Constable.
Ms Faragher questioned whether it was appropriate for the Chief Constable to retain control of the process. Mrs Poole-Wilson defended the existing arrangements, saying: ‘I do think that is an appropriate mechanism.’
However, she acknowledged the opportunity to introduce a system that was ‘suitably independent, proportionate, and cost-effective’ and commanded public confidence.
The Minister said changes were being developed to strengthen the Commissioner's oversight, with consultation on proposed legislative changes expected between April and June 2027.
She also revealed that 31 formal complaints relating to police conduct had been recorded during the most recent reporting period. Of the 15 complaints concluded in the Commissioner's latest annual report, five were partially substantiated, involving minor elements. None was wholly substantiated.
Ms Faragher, who has previously said calls for greater independence had been ‘decades in the making’, hopes her motion will force speedier reform.


.jpeg?width=455)



