I note with an appropriate sense of irony that a come-over organisation (Patriotic Alternative, Examiner, April 25) has set up shop here to complain about immigration.

The situation would be laughable were it not so serious. By no means perfect, this island has a long history of welcoming immigrants which has allowed us to adapt and grow during the radical technological and societal changes of the last 100 years or more. Indeed, we are an immigrant nation with 50.4% of people having been born off-island, the vast majority in our adjacent island nations.

I was schooled here alongside Manx, English, Scottish, Irish, Welsh, South African, Nigerian, Polish and others.

I currently work, and have worked, on island with Manx, Israeli, Dutch, Chinese, Indian, Ethiopian, Norwegian, Spanish, French, Nigerian, Romanian, Estonian, American, Canadian, Costa Rican, Indian, South African, Philippine, Australian as well as English, Irish, Welsh, and Scottish among others.

Each of these people has made a life here and has contributed immeasurably to the wealth and success of our island community.

I am myself an immigrant, moving here from Ireland when I was a child, though I suspect that’s not the kind of immigration the self-styled ‘Patriotic Alternative’ takes issue with.

The immigrant population here has expanded significantly in the last 30 years and yet Manx culture is as vibrant, if not more so, than ever.

The Manx language has grown significantly since I was a boy. Manx history, culture, and music is celebrated widely and traditions such as Hop-tu-Naa, Tynwald Day, Hunt the Wren are enjoyed by growing numbers each year.

Equally our local culture and community has been enriched by the events and traditions of those who have come here and we will continue to succeed and grow by being an open and welcoming society.

Many Manx people have also emigrated, exporting Manx culture and traditions to the countries of the world.

Our island has a proud history, a strong culture and limitless potential through the self-confidence that allows us to welcome those who can help build a better community for all.

I hope that the Manx people will take the same approach to this group of come-overs as they do to others who have sought to stir trouble and division, ‘there’s a boat in the morning’.

Martin Dunne


This letter was first published in the Examiner of May 2. The following one was printed the week afterwards:

The recent publicity given by The Isle of Man Examiner (April 25) to a dangerous fascist group which is actively trying to recruit on the island, including reproducing their leaflets and distributing them on social media, shows a blatant disregard for the welfare of those targeted by fascists and a complete lack of understanding of how these ideas take root.

Indeed, the front page of the paper was described by one of the leaders of the group as ‘amazing publicity’ in a recent social media post.

Isle of Man Examiner, April 25, 2023

While most readers will recognise fascist ideas for the bile that they are, it only takes a small percentage to be persuaded for people’s lives to be at very real risk.

Famously, in the week after the leader of the fascist British National Party was disgraced on Question Time in 2009, 3,000 people applied to join the party – a tiny percentage of the eight million who watched, but a huge increase in absolute numbers for a fringe neo-nazi group. This is the risk of publicising ideas that present an existential threat to all that is decent in society.

Across the world, laws proscribe hate speech, incitement to violence and other unacceptable actions such as marketing tobacco to children – very few people are truly ‘free speech absolutists’ who oppose such measures.

Likewise, such is the nature of the ‘paradox of tolerance’, as philosopher Karl Popper called it, that we must not extend freedom of speech to fascists, who will deny this very right to others at the first chance.

Reproducing their propaganda and circulating it to a huge audience as The Isle of Man Examiner has done is politically illiterate and utterly ignorant of the nature of the fascist threat.

This matter is especially serious given the context of the recent fearmongering about sex education in the QEII High School in Peel.

Groups such as the one recently reported on aim to sow division and hate, scapegoating the most vulnerable in society for problems which are caused by an economic system that makes the lives of so many so difficult.

In presenting immigrants and refugees as responsible for issues such as the housing crisis or austerity, fascists serve as useful idiots for the powerful, distracting attention from the real source of people’s woes. As Max Horkheimer, a Jewish refugee from Nazi Germany, famously wrote in 1939, ‘whoever is not prepared to talk about capitalism should also remain silent about fascism’.

As has often been noted, rather than beginning with death camps, fascism ends with them.

By giving such an enormous platform to a nauseating white supremacist group, the Isle of Man Examiner has unwittingly contributed to the growth of this ideology, and in doing so put at risk immigrants, people of colour, LGBT+ people, trade unionists and many more who fall afoul of the disgusting ideas spread by fascist groups. Let this mistake not be made again, and all their propaganda removed from the paper’s online presence immediately.

Anti-fascism is self-defence. No pasarán – cha jed ad shaghey!

Dr Ben Ó Ceallaigh,

Aberystwyth University, Wales

Share your views with our readers.

Write to: Opinions, Isle of Man Examiner and Manx Independent, 18 Finch Road, Douglas, IM1 2PT or email:

Don’t forget to include your name, FULL home address and a daytime phone number even if you want to be anonymous in print.

Obviously, we need to be able to verify the identity of everyone whose letter we publish.

We don’t print phone numbers or full addresses and respect anonymity if the author requests it.