A survey by Rushen Heritage Trust has found just under two third of respondents are opposed to Port Erin Commissioners’ plans for a landmark building.

The Cosy Nook cafe, which was closed last year, could be knocked down and replaced with a new modern building.

Since the plans were announced, the response from residents has not been the warmest. The RHT survey shows that 63% were against the proposed new building, 33% in favour, and 4% indifferent.

The survey was taken by 897 people, of which 37% (about 330) were Port Erin residents - and of those, 68% were against the plans, with 28% in favour.

The chairman of RHT, Hugh Davidson, said: ’We would like to thank everyone who took the time to respond to the survey.

’It is obvious that the Cosy Nook has been a much-loved café for many years and people have strong feelings about it, which was shown by almost 90% of respondents leaving comments explaining their views.

’These views are proof of the strength of feeling about the site, on both sides. With 63% voting against the new plans, it is a decisive result and, as such, the trust is therefore submitting an objection to the planning committee.’

The survey found that respondents had issues with the design including a need to retain the traditional façade so as not to lose the site’s uniqueness/character, the new building being too large, and not in keeping with the site, the site will lose its cosy/quaint/charming/tranquil aspects, parking issues/congestion, the loss of Manx character and the need to preserve heritage.

Of those in favour, many considered the plans to be exciting and forward-looking, praising the commissioners for moving with the times and showing vision.

Mr Davidson added: ’We are recommending that the new-look Cosy Nook should be a building with traditional Manx cottage style frontage, which fits the heritage setting of St Catherine’s Terrace, and links with the cosy, charming, informal characteristics of the Cosy Nook.

’The interior would need to fit modern customer requirements and provide spectacular views of the sea. Hopefully, a significant part of the internal decoration and pictures would recall and celebrate the Cosy Nook’s memorable past.

’Of course, we recognize that the substantial minority who favoured the application also had strong views, sincerely held, and courteously expressed, and appreciate their participation in the poll.

’We also respect the motivations of Port Erin Commissioners in submitting the planning application.’

The RHT has also called on the commissioners to hold a public meeting to discuss the plans which can be found on the planning website.